Retour à The Cactus & Succulent Circle

What am I doing wrong?! I’m not going to pretend I know what I’m… | The Cactus & Succulent Circle | Communauté Planta

Katherine

What am I doing wrong?! I’m not going to pretend I know what I’m doing — I bought this with little hope, a lot of delusion, and a tiny dream, and I’m actually stunned it’s lived for the month or so that it has — it even outgrew its original pot! However, it looks…confused. I am also confused! I see drooping, stretching(?), some “lifting” that looks healthy, and even some new growth in the center, but those lower leaves do not seem like they’re happy and I don’t know how to help. I sized up only 1” in pots, because it was truly overwhelming the pot it was in and I only had a 3.5” terra cotta pot available that I felt comfortable using. I’m using a full spectrum grow light 10-14 hours a day because the natural light from my east-facing window is so unreliable I don’t count it at all. I’ve been gradually increasing the power of the grow light until midday and then gradually decreasing the light again after a few hours of “full afternoon sun” until evening. Basically, I’m trying to mimic the natural sun. I feel like a lunatic, but I am bent on keeping this thing alive and thriving. I’m wondering if a second grow light (this is a small desk clip-on version because it serves only one 2.5” echeveria) would be helpful for more 360° lighting, although the plant is rotated throughout the day. I am avoiding watering more than once a week — less, ideally. I am aiming for completely dry soil before watering, and the last watering was 12 hours after repotting (just under one week ago) to hopefully encourage root growth. The original soil was left intact during repotting, with small rocks and a small amount of succulent soil added, so it didn’t require a full watering, but it felt right after transferring to a new pot. I have not watered it since then, and will wait until the soil is dry. All leaves except the absolute lowest (can’t feel those, won’t hurt the plant to try to manipulate them) are plump and firm, with some reaching toward the “sun,” others lying more flat (presumably in need of more light?) and a few leaves neither stretching nor reaching, that appear to be the healthiest. The photos below are not showing the plant as it would be directly under the grow light — it is incredibly difficult to get a photo under the light without a shadow that obscures the issues. I apologize if this makes any assistance more difficult, but I am open to a second grow light if light seems to be the immediate issue. ANY and all advice is greatly appreciated and welcomed! I have NO idea what I’m doing! Edit: all of the advice I’ve gotten has been so reassuring and kind. Thank you! Also, it’s totally a sempervivum! Sorry for mislabeling this! I’m changing the plant on my profile but any use of “echeveria” here can be replaced with “sempervivum.” :)

Pièce jointe 1 sur 2Pièce jointe 2 sur 2
5 J'aime 8 commentaires

8 commentaires

  1. Snowstorm

    Maybe someone with more experience can weight in but I think it looks really healthy! Great job!! Sounds like you’re doing everything correct. I have a simalar succulent, and mine looks the same. The top leaves point straight up and the eventually start to lay down to the sides. I only water mine when fully dry so poking a bamboo stick or a moisture metre in to check before watering since they don’t need water all that often.

    3 J'aime
    • Katherine

      Thank you for saying this! It really put me at ease. I have no idea what healthy looks like for an echeveria, and google can be so very stressful, and I am meticulously watching it for signs of gardener error — might have resulted in a little paranoia. :) I do not have a green thumb and I appreciate you weighing in! I’ll definitely keep an eye out for any other advice, maybe consider adding a lamp, but for now I’ll just leave it alone. I also use a wooden stick to check moisture levels! So far, definitely not fully dry. Thank you!

      1 j'aime
    • Snowstorm

      Of course, no worries, you’re doing a great job!! I was once there and it’s difficult when you don’t know what normal is supposed to look like. I was googling all sorts of things, like ‘what do pothos look like when they vine’ bc I didn’t know what to expect!! lol. Yours looks amazing! And succulents really don’t need much care other than strong light and water from time to time. Let yours fully dry out tho between watering. Good you’re measuring with a stick but you need to wait a little bit longer. These guys store water in their leaves so they can go a long time without water; they’re denser plants after all!! You’ll notice that the leaves get a bit wrinkly when they are under watered, so you could even use that as a marker to water.

      1 j'aime
  2. BigGrac

    Looks good to me! I will say that the changing of the grow light intensity and the daily rotating is defs unnecessary. These guys are supposed to be fun, not adding daily stress! For my succulents I just leave the grow lights on full blast and rotate when I water if I feel like it and they’re all good

    1 j'aime
    • Katherine

      Thank you for letting me know I can back off a little — I do genuinely enjoy tending to the plant, so when time allows I am happy to do a little extra. It is my only plant right now so I’m able to spend extra time on it, but clearly that’s a double edged sword — it doesn’t need much, but I have a lot to learn! As I learn how to care for it more intuitively and add more plants to my collection, I’m sure I’ll become a less involved plant parent, lol. Thank you again!

      0 J'aime
  3. Camryn

    the lower leaves on succulents often die off when new growth is happening! it’s just part of their growth cycle - it is completely normal 💖✨🌿

    3 J'aime
  4. Phil

    As hard as you are try and all the info you have gathered, you are on your way to having a green thumb. First, I think it is a sempervivum, not echeveria. But similar care. The leaves on some succulents change with waterings and amount of light. Yours look fine. Soil should be bone dry before you consider watering. Also the bottom leaves will start to feel soft or rubbery. Lights can just stay on all day. Depending on strength of your grow light, probably 14 hours a day. Less if getting some direct sun. For a pot clip on light, look for 10 watts. If they don’t mention the wattage, then it’s too weak. And full spectrum. You said succulent soil. Your sempervivum is probably fine in what you have. If you want more succulents, get better soil. It will probably look like gravel to you. Or you can amend regular potting soil with “grit”. Recipes are on line. Remember they do better with under watering than over. And some succulents will go for weeks with no water requirements. I have many. Have fun and don’t stress over them . They are replaceable.

    Pièce jointe 1 sur 3Pièce jointe 2 sur 3Pièce jointe 3 sur 3
    1 j'aime
    • Katherine

      This is all great advice — I think you might be right about the plant type! I’ll keep an eye on the soil to ensure it’s continuing to drain well, but I am definitely going to adjust my potting mix in the future. I checked my lamp wattage and we’re all good there. “Lovingly neglecting” something is strangely difficult! It is very comforting to know that so far, my set up will encourage growth, and I have a lot to work with in the future. I promise I’m having fun! Just very determined. Yours are beautiful and so vibrant! Thank you for all of the help!

      0 J'aime