Tilbage til Expert Level Greenspace

A philosophical Planty blog conundrum: So the other day I was having… | Expert Level Greenspace | Planta-fællesskab

Danika

A philosophical Planty blog conundrum: So the other day I was having this moral dilemma in my head and this realization occurred to me… Has anyone ever seen the old 1970s movie called The Secret Life of Plants, about plants and the study where they attach plants to electrical meters similar to ones you would put on a human for brain waves, with energetic response, to see if plants had “feelings”. Well, if you have seen it, you'll remember that they performed some interesting experiments and that they found the plants had wild electro responses to individual human beings. The video showed a person hacking up a head of cabbage into pieces right next to the plant hooked up to a meter and then left and came back the next day. As soon as that person walked into the room, that plant that was still hooked up started to freak out electromagnetically. It somehow remembered which human was caring for it, and which human was a danger to it. Amazing movie. Who knows how real the “science” really was, but super fascinating none-the-less. I also watched a recent YouTube video called “Can This Plant /Actually/ See?” about a study they did on plants that shows a particular variety of plant that can shape-shift due to being able to see! They theorize about if plants can therefore see US! 😮 Pretty fascinating sciency video! Highly recommend watching if you want your mind 🤯! Anyways, this got me thinking… I have somehow acquired over 250 houseplants over the last few years, and have grown quite attached to most of them to the point where I set aside a lot of other things that I could be doing in my life, but I don't do them because I put my plants first as if they were my children. I know they are just plants, but since they are living beings, I know that if I don't water them and care for them, they will suffer and possibly die. I can't allow myself as a good plant parent to allow that to happen, so I choose to prioritize them first above a lot of other things. So the other day I was making a salad for dinner and it dawned on me that I wonder if my house plants got upset by watching me eat salad… 🤔😝 I then had this moment when I was researching a particular house plant of mine and it stated that the leaves were actually edible! I thought “oh my gosh, that's crazy, I would never chop up my house plant leaves and eat them!” Ha ha, hilarious given that I was just sitting there eating a salad, not quite connecting the fact that my house plants and plants we grow for food are really no different. Other than the fact that we put them on different pedestals, and one we keep for visual esthetics versus the other, we grow for sustenance. It was pretty funny in my mind when I realize this, because throughout my life, I have vacillated between being a vegetarian, pescatarian, vegan and carnivore. Currently, I found a good balance of nothing super strict or “everything in moderation”, about 80% vegetarian 10% pescatarian 5%, vegan and 5% carnivore. So this whole thought process about eating my house plants made me think about how we all put so much energy and care and love into our house plants, so much so that for a moment I questioned, “Is it any different than having a pet animal of some kind and then eating it?” My friends have chickens, and one of them got injured by a wild animal and they had to euthanize it so it wouldn't suffer and I asked them if they were going to eat it and they said, “no way, we are so attached to that chicken, she turned into our pet… we just can't bring our selves to do it!” Even though that's why they got the chickens in the first place was to eat the eggs, etc. etc. So there seems to be this thing that happens when any living thing becomes your pet, that like you can no longer eat them and I'm like, “well am I going to starve because I can't eat vegetables or salad anymore on top of other things i won’t eat?!” 😂 Yeah, so the Plant mom struggle has gotten to a whole new level of real. Then I ate my salad. 🤣

Vedhæftet fil 1 af 1
16 likes 12 kommentarer

12 kommentarer

  1. Plant Father

    i was reading about this recently, the way plants communicate is so fascinating. there was a study they did on tomato and tobacco plants, testing the frequencies they emit when “stressed” (dehydrated or wounded in this case), and found that they do essentially scream in pain the same way animals do… fascinating, but a little disturbing too.

    6 likes
    • Danika

      Totally disturbing! Do you by chance recall what that study was called or name of thing you watched/read? I’d love to see it!

      1 like
    • Plant Father

      i read an article from the smithsonian on it, there’s even a link to the study. try searching “Plants May Let Out Ultrasonic Squeals When Stressed” on google, that is the name of the article. what is most fascinating to me is the possibility that our pets can hear these sounds. bats, mice, and other creatures with the ability to hear ultrasonic wavelengths definitely can though, since the plants ‘voices’ are so high pitched.

      2 likes
    • Danika

      Wow! And thanks! Going to look this up!

      2 likes
    • Rhonda

      There was recently a Science Friday podcast that talked about sounds being picked up from stressed plants

      2 likes
  2. Eliya

    I’ve thought about all of this soooo much. Mainly when it comes to animals. I live in the country, and I befriend the cows and chickens and pigs, and I find that they all have personalities and enjoy scratches, and know who you are when you come by. And then I realize that any animals of the species has the same intelectual capacity, and suddenly I’m plant-based for the day. Lol

    4 likes
  3. Lazy Gardener

    First of all, any emotions any one of us feel about our plants, are valid. However, biologically, plants do not have a nervous system. So any sense of pain do not exist to them. At the basic level, all living things respond to the environment. Think of a Venus fly trap. It does not close because it can sense food. They close as a response to two hair-like structures being manipulated within seconds of one another. This is how they close if one decides to put jelly food in their traps. Plants can respond to light, but not like eyes. Is there light, yes or no. If there is not enough light, it will respond by producing hormones to grow towards the light. Similarly, if a bush is eaten by a deer, it will respond by producing hormones. These hormones will then be received by another plant, which will respond by producing toxins, etc. So, enjoy the salad. I, for one, will not get any nutrients eating rocks.

    1 like
    • Danika

      Ha ha ha! Yeah rocks for dinner sounds like a dismal existence! Thank you for your wisdom! All good to know, this perspective gives me a deeper understanding! I feel like there is so much we still don’t understand about the kingdom of plants… one never knows exactly what is going on in each creature and what it is to exist within its “reality”. I am open to all interpretations. Have you (or anyone) ever seen the fellow on you-tube who does videos about difference species of animals (cats, dogs, squirrels, hummingbirds, snakes, etc etc etc) and based on their biological make up (and using certain meters) he can determine how fast time is moving for that animal (each has a different experience of time than humans, some faster, some slower) and that combined with how they see (spiders with tons of eyes, dogs with partial color blindness, other animals only see in black and white, etc etc) he shows a mini-clip slowed down or sped up to the speed of its reality and with the color spectrum it sees in, and we get to experience that animals reality! Mind blown when i saw this! 🤯 Would be amazing if he could show us plants “reality”!

      2 likes
    • Danika

      Oh! Found the video! Dug it up! 🤓

      Vedhæftet fil 1 af 1
      2 likes
    • Danika

      He does actually talk about plants at the very end of video and shows an experiment he is running on algae. Good stuff!

      2 likes
  4. Lazy Gardener

    Yes, absolutely fascinating. I especially like seeing how birds, bees, butterflies, moths etc. see and smell plants and flowers! Like how a plain white flower with a mild scent to us, can be psychedelic and intoxicating to them.

    3 likes
  5. Katelynn

    This is such a true story!!!

    2 likes