---
title: "Can someone please help me ID these? Just picked them up today and no…"
description: "Can someone please help me ID these? Just picked them up today and no app is giving me any results that are stalked like this. I was thinking the one on the…"
url: "https://getplanta.com/community/vOLjreBcQ-OpqrHIhVSc4w/649f977ee5a6ae6355175ce2"
community: "The Cactus & Succulent Circle"
author: "Rodolfo P."
published: "2023-07-01T03:03:26.802Z"
language: "en"
image: "https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/7s-9Gd65E_RsTk3Zo01xszy-bTwbdO6KdfSm4Ce5gyk/3fbeddd3616e421a89539bd9f087c1b2.webp?size=large"
---

[Community](https://getplanta.com/community.md) / [The Cactus \& Succulent Circle](https://getplanta.com/community/vOLjreBcQ-OpqrHIhVSc4w.md)

# Can someone please help me ID these? Just picked them up today and no…

_Posted by Rodolfo P. on 2023-07-01_

Can someone please help me ID these? Just picked them up today and no app is giving me any results that are stalked like this. I was thinking the one on the left might be Echevaria affinis but I’m not too sure. And the one on the right I keep getting Graptopetalum macdougalii which I think is right but again I haven’t found any pictures of ones like this. Are these just props from larger plants hence the stalk or what’s going on?

![Attachment 1 of 1](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/7s-9Gd65E_RsTk3Zo01xszy-bTwbdO6KdfSm4Ce5gyk/3fbeddd3616e421a89539bd9f087c1b2.webp?size=large)

## 4 comments

### Nina commented on 2023-07-01

The one in the right is a ghost plant

#### Rodolfo P. replied on 2023-07-01

Thank you!

### Planta member commented on 2023-07-02

The one on the left kinda looks like a black prince that lost a lot of leaves. I say this because of the white calluses on the stem.

### Rhonda commented on 2023-07-03

They’re fine examples of plants who had leggy starts early in life that have grown beautiful all the same. Tough spirits.

---

_Source: the Planta community (https://getplanta.com). Reading is open to everyone. To post, comment and like, get the Planta app: https://getplanta.com/download_