---
title: "This is a PSA to newbies about what type of soil to avoid buying.…"
description: "This is a PSA to newbies about what type of soil to avoid buying. Some of us may believe Miracle Grow soil is fine to work with, and that their plants have…"
url: "https://getplanta.com/community/lZ7uAE3pQ86jnFGxrCwLrg/QSHj6ET6BpmZanogHs3Tta"
community: "Anything about plants"
author: "Adrian"
published: "2026-11-17T16:28:20.830708Z"
language: "en"
image: "https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/CQyscbeN5f0KZltdaSyx3VQZZh8uHYoaKDmCZlFICjE/9UIdtn_LAXMbv-elvuNqa.webp?size=large"
---

[Community](https://getplanta.com/community.md) / [Anything about plants](https://getplanta.com/community/lZ7uAE3pQ86jnFGxrCwLrg.md)

# This is a PSA to newbies about what type of soil to avoid buying.…

_Posted by Adrian on 2026-11-17_

This is a PSA to newbies about what type of soil to avoid buying. Some of us may believe Miracle Grow soil is fine to work with, and that their plants have survived it, but if you live in the east coast of the US, tropical regions, or any places with ANY humidity in the spring or summer, I’d recommend you read this. As a disclaimer, I’m discussing their soil for houseplants, not their soil for gardening.

And for anyone who feels the need to argue with me about Miracle Grow and say their plant is fine with it, this is what was left of my abuela’s jade last week after a matter of a few months following my aunt repotting it with Miracle Grow’s cactus mix. She said she hadn’t watered it in 3 months, and the soil was well over 50% moist. I was absolutely mortified, and had to save what I could because the biggest jade I’ve ever seen had 3 sole roots still attached to it because of the rot that soil caused. The leaves and branches started falling off at the touch in droves, and I had to chop off and propagate any healthy branches that I could to save what was left of it. This jade is 60+ years old, and I had to inform my aunt that the mother plant is pretty much already dead.

1\. There isn’t a self-respecting nursery in the state of Pennsylvania that sells it, and I’m not joking when I say the ones around me literally want the stuff banned. Lowe’s and Home Depot have a deal with MG to sell their brand exclusively. Walmart also sells it. For the past decade or so, there has been a consensus amongst a good chunk of the houseplant community that the soil is poor on purpose, the same way some plants from box stores aren’t properly put in the right soil, to kill your plant off and make you think you are the one doing something wrong, making you buy another bag of soil or a new plant from the same store. It’s not you. It’s the soil.

2\. If you live in a desert or very dry states like Arizona, California, or the Midwest, the plant might survive the soil, but it is very cheap, peat-heavy soil, including their cactus mix, and you have to add A LOT of extra amendments to try to make it remotely usable, which makes it less cheap in the long run when you have to spend extra to make it remotely adequate. If you live anywhere with any remote humidity in the spring/summer/fall or a more tropical climate, that soil is going to take an eon to dry out, even indoors. The only thing I would buy from them is their perlite and orchid bark bags. All of their soil is very peat-heavy, which means it retains a lot of moisture for a long time. This makes it prone to overwatering, root rot, and fungus gnats. I haven’t had a single bag of Miracle Grow that didn’t contain or LEAD TO fungus gnats.

3\. Anything I have ever repotted with Miracle Grow nearly died or did die within a week from root rot. Over half of the plants I’ve had to rescue for friends and family were plants that were recently repotted in Miracle Grow that suddenly started dying. Two of my local nurseries had a repotting counter solely for the sake or rescuing customers’ plants from the customer recently repotting it in Miracle Grow. I did a test once with their cactus mix to see how long it would take for a pot of the soil alone to dry out indoors. After 2 MONTHS, it was still about 70% moist. I live in Pennsylvania, and I have yet to see a single houseplant that’s been in Miracle Grow soil that wasn’t in distress or DOA that I’ve had to take care of.

Almost weekly, I see people posting on Planta asking what they did wrong after repotting a plant, following all the steps they saw online, and the only thing they did differently is repot it in Miracle Grow soil. The plant either shows signs of overwatering or root rot even when they haven’t watered it yet following a repot. I am very used to walking users through rescuing a plant from root rot because of MG.

For people in the east coast, especially those in the PA/NJ area, I beg you to go to a local nursery instead for your soil instead of Lowe’s or Home Depot. There are cheaper soils that are better quality than Miracle Grow there. I’d like to end this on a lighter note by inviting anyone to recommend their favorite soil brand, especially if it is more affordable. I personally swear by Espoma’s soil. They have pre-mixed soil for anything from cacti to orchids, as well as liquid fertilizer similar to Miracle Grow. They are a local brand based in NJ and I have never had a problem with their soil. It usually runs for about $6-9 in PA. They have everything MG provides in terms of soil mixes, amendments, and fertilizer. Please try them instead if you’re on a tight budget.

![Attachment 1 of 2](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/CQyscbeN5f0KZltdaSyx3VQZZh8uHYoaKDmCZlFICjE/9UIdtn_LAXMbv-elvuNqa.webp?size=large)

![Attachment 2 of 2](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/CQyscbeN5f0KZltdaSyx3VQZZh8uHYoaKDmCZlFICjE/iJQqNK2kr50c_OipGUjRY.webp?size=large)

## 3 comments

### Adrian commented on 2026-11-17

And to clarify, I’m well aware that even quality soil brands can come with fungus gnats. I’m saying the soil is so moist all the time that it very often attracts or comes with fungus gnats because of how long it takes for even their cactus mix to dry out.

I don’t mean for this to come off as a rant. This is something I’ve discussed in length with local nurseries over the years. I’m very upset about what happened to my abuela’s jade. She has since passed away and that jade is a very beloved family heirloom that my aunt would take cuttings from and gift to her nieces and nephews. My abuela gave a cutting to my mom when she bought her first house and it recently turned 30, and it breaks my heart that a really beautiful 60+ year-old jade is also no longer with us. Caring for our piece of that jade is what got me into caring for houseplants in the first place. I made this post as an informational warning because of just how awful that soil is. I don’t want anyone else to go through losing a really beloved plant, especially an heirloom one like a jade or holiday cactus, to this soil.

### Tracy Lee commented on 2026-11-18

Thank you Adrian! Important for new plant parents to know. It’s not difficult to see for yourself if you understand what the moisture level should be worth your plant.

### Ondra's Gardyn commented on 2026-11-20

Totally agree! In the beginning of my plant parenting I purchased a bag of MG from HD and upon opening it gnats were present so I attempted to return the bag but the store refused to take it back. Since then Ive stayed from big box stores and buy from local nurseries. I live around several farms which have farmers markets and some offer quality soil.

---

_Source: the Planta community (https://getplanta.com). Reading is open to everyone. To post, comment and like, get the Planta app: https://getplanta.com/download_
