--- title: "Hey there!! I got these from my friends succulents while I was…" description: "Hey there!! I got these from my friends succulents while I was visiting. 🤫 but dont worry, she let me. Will these propagate? If I put them in water will they…" url: "https://getplanta.com/community/lZ7uAE3pQ86jnFGxrCwLrg/PoDMT-eYRbqsy2k3K5qboA?language=ja" community: "Anything about plants" author: "LearningPlantMom" published: "2024-04-05T00:19:39.963519Z" language: "en" image: "https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/QsglYOZah3J0dczvSzmJYWy_zhTPPcC6NI0e3Vd8578/MQXFdXgZToGJ_tPHLMtQGA.webp?size=large" --- [コミュニティ](https://getplanta.com/community.md?language=ja) / [Anything about plants](https://getplanta.com/community/lZ7uAE3pQ86jnFGxrCwLrg.md?language=ja) # Hey there!! I got these from my friends succulents while I was… _LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-05に投稿しました_ Hey there!! I got these from my friends succulents while I was visiting. 🤫 but dont worry, she let me. Will these propagate? If I put them in water will they grow roots? ![1件中1件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/QsglYOZah3J0dczvSzmJYWy_zhTPPcC6NI0e3Vd8578/MQXFdXgZToGJ_tPHLMtQGA.webp?size=large) ## 13件のコメント ### NikoScyさんが2024-04-05にコメントしました Need better pictures. Look like dead/rotting leaves of a Crassula maybe? Can’t really tell what they are… probably don’t put them in water though if you’re trying to propagate- wait for the roots to grow and the mother leaf to die #### LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-05に返信しました How will the roots grow? Should I put them in anything, or just leave them on a plate? Do I need to do anything to ensure growth of roots? #### NikoScyさんが2024-04-05に返信しました Depends on the plant! Do you know what plant they came from? #### LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-05に返信しました I think that was one of them ![1件中1件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/QsglYOZah3J0dczvSzmJYWy_zhTPPcC6NI0e3Vd8578/L6LyLclzRE6dMAAEe9bsAQ.webp?size=large) #### LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-05に返信しました And that definitely was the other one ![1件中1件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/QsglYOZah3J0dczvSzmJYWy_zhTPPcC6NI0e3Vd8578/Pk0Kh8FpSP6KYEFy3EF72w.webp?size=large) ### Molly 🪴さんが2024-04-05にコメントしました The first one is a hobbit finger jade and the bottom is a zebra plant. I don’t have experience with propagating either of them specifically, but definitely don’t put them in water. The zebra plant cutting is probably just fine to sit on top of some dry soil until it starts growing roots, at which point you could start giving it some water. I think that jades only grow if you cut a node with it, so I doubt your leaf will do anything, but it doesn’t hurt to try! Treating it the same way as the zebra plant will be your best bet. #### NikoScyさんが2024-04-06に返信しました Nope, can’t prop zebra leaves - the jade you can! You’ve got em backwards! ### Plant Fatherさんが2024-04-06にコメントしました it’s not okay to steal pieces of your friends’ plants. i would be quite upset if i discovered a friend had taken leaves off my succulents, especially slow growing ones like haworthia… better to ask for cuttings in the future. as far as i know, haworthia can’t be propagated from leaf cuttings. they send out offshoots or pups like aloe and grow in a clumping pattern. the plant can be divided to propagate. i think the other leaf looks too dead to grow roots #### LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-06に返信しました What are you talking about stealing? #### Plant Fatherさんが2024-04-06に返信しました in this post and your duplicate post, before my comment influenced you to edit them, you said you “secretly” (without permission) took leaves from your friend’s plants. taking things secretly or without permission is theft. also, for future reference, duplicate posts are not allowed as it clutters the feed. i would recommend reading the community rules, accessible via the little (i) icon in the top right corner ### NikoScyさんが2024-04-06にコメントしました That’s what I thought they were! The jade will prop, just set it on dirt. Don’t water it for months; wait until a baby plant has sprouted and rooted, and the mother leaf is dead. The zebra you can throw away, it won’t prop from the leaf. #### NikoScyさんが2024-04-06に返信しました Tho… the jade leaf looks dead and rotted, so may not have much luck with propagating that one. Ask your friend for one, it’s no big deal to take a piece off #### LearningPlantMomさんが2024-04-06に返信しました Thank you! --- _Plantaコミュニティ (https://getplanta.com)。閲覧はどなたでも可能です。投稿、コメント、いいねをするには、Plantaアプリをダウンロードしてください: https://getplanta.com/download_