---
title: "Are these propagations dead? They’ve been in water for abt 3 weeks.…"
description: "Are these propagations dead? They’ve been in water for abt 3 weeks. (With changed water) the leaves are still really green and it’s still really firm. What’s…"
url: "https://getplanta.com/community/lKxUkhzRR_aIJD7o1QvtwQ/VWv1RrouGbc7o6x0xyFHYq?language=ja"
community: "Pests, diseases and problems"
author: "Oksana 🥎🍦🌱"
published: "2025-05-23T21:09:50.068815Z"
language: "en"
image: "https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/WE6UBkopcRECYPrP8RqCmGM4YVEKsigk8jAnxgxqy4k/u5udTvq0TvuixiPTuCKacg.webp?size=large"
---

[コミュニティ](https://getplanta.com/community.md?language=ja) / [Pests, diseases and problems](https://getplanta.com/community/lKxUkhzRR_aIJD7o1QvtwQ.md?language=ja)

# Are these propagations dead? They’ve been in water for abt 3 weeks.…

_Oksana 🥎🍦🌱さんが2025-05-23に投稿しました_

Are these propagations dead? They’ve been in water for abt 3 weeks. (With changed water) the leaves are still really green and it’s still really firm. What’s going on? Will they root? Btw they are 3 different props

![3件中1件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/WE6UBkopcRECYPrP8RqCmGM4YVEKsigk8jAnxgxqy4k/u5udTvq0TvuixiPTuCKacg.webp?size=large)

![3件中2件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/WE6UBkopcRECYPrP8RqCmGM4YVEKsigk8jAnxgxqy4k/9FguLpm8RhKsh6ooWXHlpw.webp?size=large)

![3件中3件目の添付ファイル](https://images.getplanta.com/v1/resize/WE6UBkopcRECYPrP8RqCmGM4YVEKsigk8jAnxgxqy4k/uDbKu_keTyejQiDX1kGQxQ.webp?size=large)

## 5件のコメント

### PhiloFoxさんが2025-05-23にコメントしました

I wouldn't give up until or unless they turn brown, black, and mushy. I always hope lol

#### Oksana 🥎🍦🌱さんが2025-05-23に返信しました

Thanks! 🙏 I won’t. I see what I think is a root on photo 3 so I’m praying lol

### plantmotherさんが2025-05-23にコメントしました

These look just fine! In fact the bottom right looks like it actually has a root sprouting!! These water propagations are just a waiting game unfortunately :( but they look healthy!

### Patriciaさんが2025-05-23にコメントしました

Some of mine took longer than others. The plant will grow roots when it’s ready unless it has disease on it but it will brown and rot if it is. I use prop drops for mine and it works great

### Bon Tasticさんが2025-05-28にコメントしました

I'd stop changing the water. Plants release rooting hormone and you're essentially getting rid of it with every change. Additionally you could ad a Jade pothos cutting to the mix they help stimulate root growth.

---

_Plantaコミュニティ (https://getplanta.com)。閲覧はどなたでも可能です。投稿、コメント、いいねをするには、Plantaアプリをダウンロードしてください: https://getplanta.com/download_